24-Hour Warehouse Traffic Rebuked
By Holly Crocco
Several impassioned residents showed up to the Nov. 5 Southeast Town Board meeting for a public hearing regarding a request by Lincoln Logistics to amend its special permit application to allow overnight truck deliveries to the distribution center on Pugsley Road.
The Southeast Planning Board voted in August to amend the statement of findings from the 2021 environmental impact statement for Lincoln Logistics to support removal of the condition that trucks cannot operate overnight, citing that review of traffic and noise showed there would be no adverse impact.
The matter was then sent to the town board, which will vote on it in the near future.
On Nov. 5, David Steinmetz of Zarin & Steinmetz, representing the applicant, explained that when the development of the property was given the green light five years ago, it was with the constraint that no overnight truck traffic would be allowed. However, such restrictions have made it hard for the property owner to find tenants to lease the space.
“There is abundant case law in the State of New York that says there’s a really high barrier for local government regulating business activities,” he said. “You can regulate under zoning use and the location of uses, but you can’t really regulate hours of operation.”
Steinmetz noted that Ace Endico has no limitation on its hours of operation.
Nonetheless, the stipulation was put in place five years ago, and the law allows the client to come back to argue that a condition of the agreement doesn’t make sense.
Theresa Brandon-Simao of the Tonetta Lake area said she’s already being woken up nightly by truck traffic on Interstate 84, and that allowing those trucks on the local roads overnight will only increase the noise.
“Ace Endico is nothing; to even compare it is embarrassing for you,” she said. “Ace Endico is a tiny building compared to what is up on that hill.”
Samantha Woodgate, who also lives along Tonetta Lake, echoed those sentiments.
“The sound travels and I’m hoping, as a town board, you will protect the residents that butt up against the warehouse,” she said. “Because if I can hear the highway noise, I’ll hear this warehouse as well.”
Ann Fanizzi of Hunter’s Glen said she expects the town to honor the agreement that was made five years ago.
“That was the document the residents of this town agreed to and that the developer agreed to,” she said. “And now because it was inconvenient for him because he could not make money, because he could not get fees, because he could not get someone to go into a 600,000-square-foot building, we the residents have to bear the burden of that? That was a business decision he made.”
Bill Nulk, chairman of the Putnam County Industrial Development Agency, spoke in support of the removal of stipulations, which “handicap the project from actually fulfilling its full capabilities. They have gone through a great deal of revisions to take a look and change the necessary things and prove they are not excessively noisy,” he said. “They should be able to operate the way a warehouse operates.”
Kathleen Abels, president of the county’s Economic Development Corporation and a resident of Brewster, agreed.
“My job is to attract, support, and promote businesses because they’re important to our tax base,” she said. “If people who live here want relief from their taxes, they need business… Retaining a for-profit property owner will help pay our school, town, and county real estate taxes. That’s very important for me.”
A resident of Hunter’s Glen expressed disappointment that despite months of residents turning out to oppose 24-hour operations at the site, the planning board moved forward with the change, “signaling that out-of-state corporate interests outweigh the well-being of the constituents you were elected to represent. The developer built this warehouse fully aware of their daytime-only trucking restrictions,” she said. “Their inability to find a tenant is private and financial risk. It should not be solved by permanently disrupting the peace, sleep, and health of Southeast residents.”
The August approval by the planning board to amend the special permit was passed 4-3, with members James King, Lynne Eckardt, and David Rush voting “no.” The motion to send the matter to the town board passed by a vote of 5-2, with Eckardt and Rush voting “no.”
During the hearing, Scott Seaman said that while everyone has the right to run their business, they still have to work within the rules.
“A community has the right to decide how we want to exist – how we want business to exist, how we want to interact with each other,” he said. “And if the community decides this is not the type of structure we want, these are not the hours we want, these are what we rely on our community board members to uphold.”
Steve Mattson said he doesn’t like that the applicant is trying to “change the rules of the game.”
“I’m pro-business, I’m pro-entrepreneurs, but here’s the thing: we all agreed on this,” he said. “The rules of the game were negotiated. Business owners take risk. It’s not working out? Too bad… As a town board, don’t let their argument push you around. Stick to the rules we agreed to. Protect the quality of life for the residents.”
Former Southeast Town Board member John Lord recalled how, when the stipulation was agreed upon, it was not something the applicant wanted but had to accept to get the approval. “Now they realize that it didn’t work out for them, but that was the rule,” he said.
Steinmetz claimed that the goal of allowing overnight truck traffic is not to increase the quantity of deliveries, but redistribute them.
“The facility is only as big as the facility is,” he said. “It can only handle as much material that would come in and go out based upon both buildings, based upon their size… Your board and the planning board approved a 24-seven, 365-day-a-year operation; we’re not asking to change that. People are distorting that a little bit. We are trying to have ‘nighttime scheduled truck access.’ Those are your words, not ours.”
Further, Steinmetz said it’s not uncommon for business owners and property owners to seek upgrades, adaptations, and overall change to their properties.
“There’s nothing wrong with asking for an amendment,” he said. “You’re not bound by that which you bought into forever.”
In addition, he pointed out that the planning board determined overnight truck traffic would have no adverse impacts on the environment.
“If you want to disagree with me and with my client and our experts, you need to realize you’re actually disagreeing with your planning board, with your planning consultant, and with the conclusion of that board, and what that binding resolution amending the findings stands for,” said Steinmetz.
“The trucks are there anyway,” he continued. “Nothing prohibits the trucks from moving around the site at night… What we’re trying to do is make sure folks who actually use warehouses along the Route 84 corridor and beyond can use this one the way they use everything else, which is 24 hours.”
The Southeast Town Board closed the public hearing, with a decision expected to be made at an upcoming meeting. If approved, the matter will go back to the planning board for amended site plan approval.

Comments